COMMENTS
Dave.
Good points - but I still feel the same way. Guess I was one of the 15%. But confrontation can just as easily happen on a one on one basis and during some well planned quality time. Most salespeople good sales people enjoy a little private confrontation. That said we always insruct clients to not base a layoff or termination "simply on the numbers" because there is more to consider. Your A player who seems to enjoy the ultimatum might actually be underperforming in a number of other areas and yet are able to walk away from the ultimatum needing to change little if anything - of course they embrace the program - it is written for them. The " C" players wouldn't respond in either case so it is really a waste of breath. but the "B" players - like the middle class in political economics - that take the brunt. Trying to move to an A position they become defocused and discouraged rather than energized and encouraged. they start to feel underappreciated and grouped in with the people they are trying to separate themselves from and grow out of. My ultimatums were always individual and not group based. There were simply too many variables.Then again algebra was never my strong point maybe that is why I was in the 15%.
Glad you haven't backed down Frank! I read your recent post in your blog where you said that you were the best sales manager you ever met! So that would, in fact, have placed you in that group of the fewer than 15% who had the skills and put in the time!
Way to go Frank!
Hmmm...what we have here is a failure to communicate. Dave, I think you like strong, aggressive terms for behavior like ultimatum and confrontation. Good for you..that is your comfort zone. But, I think there are behaviors that address performance issues that can be labeled with other terms that do not carry such negative connotations so perhaps the root of the problem here is not a disagreement on issue resolution but simply one of semantics.
PS - Mind you I have been called confrontational for most of my adult life. Not only would I confront the skunk, I would rip it's head off and eat it!
'Put down that coffee. Coffee is for closers.
DaveKulanGlenRoss
What happens when the group you pitched this "ultimatum" to responds with eat shi* and die? A mutiny can destroy all of your percieved power and make you lame. You had better be ready to execute whatever ultimatum you barf onto people or mutiny is what you will get.
@ultimatum mutiny
Perhaps, if the entire bunch of non performers left, we would be better off!