Sales Assessment Says He’s Weak but He Made President’s Club

Yesterday a well meaning Sales Manager, in defense of his salesperson, asked me how a salesperson who made “Club” could possibly assess so poorly.  It’s a great question with a dozen or more possible explanations.  Here are some:

  • One or two big hits – exceptions rather than sustained performance
  • Existing accounts grew
  • Accounts were inherited
  • Had help closing his accounts
  • Been in the industry for a long time and was well known and well respected
  • Owns the biggest accounts
  • Owns the richest territory
  • All renewal business
  • Large portion of call-in business
  • Opportunity knocks – in the right place at the right time
  • Had the opportunities in the pipeline forever and they finally closed
  • Had exceptional marketing support to generate interest and leads

Rather than asking how someone who has achieved success could assess so poorly, what if I asked this tried and true question:  If you take away all of his existing business, customers,  sales manager, leads, call-ins and pipeline, and told him he had six months to go out and find and close 50% of a year’s quota, how would he do?